Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Ball v. Colvin

United States District Court, N.D. Indiana, Fort Wayne Division

February 28, 2014

RONALD E. BALL, Plaintiff,
CAROLYN W. COLVIN, [1] Acting Commissioner of Social Security, Defendant.


ROGER B. COSBEY, Magistrate Judge.

Plaintiff Ronald Ball appeals to the district court from a final decision of the Commissioner of Social Security ("Commissioner") denying his application under the Social Security Act (the "Act") for a period of disability and Disability Insurance Benefits ("DIB").[2] (Docket # 1.) For the following reasons, the Commissioner's decision will be REVERSED, and the case will be REMANDED to the Commissioner for further proceedings in accordance with this Opinion and Order.


Ball applied for DIB in October 2009, alleging disability as of June 24, 2008. (Tr. 162-71.) The Commissioner denied his application initially and upon reconsideration, and Ball requested an administrative hearing. (Tr. 90-93, 125-30.) On April 7, 2011, a hearing was conducted by Administrative Law Judge ("ALJ") John Pope, at which Ball, who was represented by counsel, and a vocational expert ("VE") testified. (Tr. 34-78.) On July 14, 2011, the ALJ rendered an unfavorable decision to Ball, concluding that he was not disabled because he could perform a significant number of jobs in the economy despite the limitations caused by his impairments. (Tr. 16-29.) The Appeals Council denied his request for review, at which point the ALJ's decision became the final decision of the Commissioner. (Tr. 1-12, 79-86, 264-81.)

Ball filed a complaint with this Court on October 22, 2012, seeking relief from the Commissioner's final decision. (Docket # 1.) In this appeal, Ball argues that the ALJ: (1) improperly discounted the credibility of Ball's mental health symptom testimony; and (2) failed to adequately incorporate Ball's moderate difficulties in concentration, persistence, and pace into the RFC and the hypothetical posed to the VE. (Opening Br. of Pl. in Social Security Appeal Pursuant to L.R. 7.3 ("Opening Br.") 6-11.)


A. Background

At the time of the ALJ's decision, Ball was forty-seven years old, had a high school education, and had worked as an automobile assembler for Chrysler Corporation from 1997 to June 2008; he also had past work experience as a surgical support health aide. (Tr. 41, 164, 262, 399.) Ball alleges that he is disabled due to degenerative disc disease, sleep apnea, post traumatic stress disorder ("PTSD"), attention deficit hyperactivity disorder ("ADHD"), and depression. (Opening Br. 2.) Because he challenges only the ALJ's findings concerning his mental impairments (Opening Br. 2 n.1), the Court will focus on the evidence pertaining to Ball's mental, rather than physical, limitations.

At the hearing, Ball stated that he lived with his girlfriend in a mobile home. (Tr. 40.) He was laid off from his assembler job at Chrysler in 2008; he applied for other jobs but was unsuccessful. (Tr. 42-45.) Ball is independent with his self care and goes shopping alone if needed; he also visits his mother each week. (Tr. 53-54, 58.) In his spare time, Ball enjoys going to the shooting range; riding his motorcycle; and serving as the quartermaster of the local VFW, which involves financial management. (Tr. 54, 59, 69.) In a typical day, Ball rises early and packs his girlfriend's lunch, but then usually lies back down. (Tr. 50-51.) By mid-morning, he performs household chores, including laundry, vacuuming, and unloading the dishwasher; and watches television. (Tr. 51-52, 54.) Once his girlfriend returns home, they fix dinner or go out to eat and then watch television. (Tr. 52-53.)

When asked about how his psychological conditions affect his ability to work, Ball stated that he used to feel anxious just getting out of the car at work, as well as "hyper, " which others mistook for anger. (Tr. 55-56, 70.) He added that he would have an absenteeism problem and difficulties with concentration, but no problem getting along with others. (Tr. 59, 70-71.) He had been receiving treatment for his psychological conditions through the Veterans' Administration ("VA") since 2005. (Tr. 56.) Currently, he was seeing a VA psychologist two to three times a month and a psychiatrist once a month, and participating in a PTSD group. (Tr. 56-57.)

B. Summary of the Relevant Medical Evidence

In March 2007, Ball underwent a mental status exam by Dr. Elizabeth Martin, a psychiatrist, at the VA. (Tr. 833-34.) His mood, insight, and judgment were fair, and his thought process ruminative. (Tr. 834.) He reported a suicidal thought from the night before, but otherwise none in the past several weeks. (Tr. 834.) No psychosis or suicidal plan or intent were noted. (Tr. 834.) He admitted that he drinks beer, but was adamant that he would not return to hard liquor, fearing it would lead to a black-out or hurting someone. (Tr. 834.) Dr. Martin assessed that Ball had depression and possible PTSD and ADHD, and adjusted his medications. (Tr. 834.) Dr. Martin, or another VA psychiatrist, saw Ball approximately twenty-five times from January 2007 to December 2010. (Tr. 517, 607, 630, 633, 666, 677, 758, 768, 904, 907, 924, 940, 979, 1000, 1025, 1044, 1049, 1057, 1062, 1070, 1077-79.) He was assigned Global Assessment of Functioning ("GAF") scores ranging from 55 to 65, reflecting moderate or mild mental health symptoms, in 2008 to 2010.[4] (Tr. 383-85, 666, 758, 768.)

In January 2007, Ball began seeing Birgette Miller, a psychologist, for fifty-minute sessions of psychotherapy. (Tr. 854.) He saw her approximately 120 times from January 2007 to March 2011. (Tr. 426, 441, 448, 464, 467, 469, 471, 477, 485-86, 488, 507, 510, 514, 520, 530, 532, 534, 598, 604, 609, 612-13, 616, 621, 625, 644, 647, 653, 658, 661-62, 664, 670-71, 673, 675, 680, 682, 687, 690, 741-42, 745, 750, 754, 761, 773, 779, 783, 786, 789, 793, 797, 805, 827, 829-30, 840-42, 846, 850, 854, 891, 893-94, 900, 902, 908-09, 914, 925, 933, 935-39, 942, 965, 970, 978, 986, 988, 990, 992, 995, 997-99, 1002, 1004, 1011, 1022, 1024, 1028, 1031, 1033, 1035, 1038-39, 1043, 1045, 1047, 1056, 1059, 1060, 1066, 1068-69, 1076, 1079.)

Dr. Miller assigned Ball GAF scores ranging from 56 to 64, reflecting moderate or mild symptoms, in 2007 to 2009. (Tr. 383-85.) During several visits from February 2010 through March 2011, she administered the Beck Depression and Beck Anxiety tests to Ball, and he consistently scored in the "severe" category. (Tr. 599, 645, 648, 651, 656, 774, 783, 794.) Dr. Miller periodically encouraged Ball to pursue ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.